The Last Echo of the Myth
By Edmondo Filippini
The myth often associated with an author's late works typically equates to the renown garnered over the centuries. The prevailing narrative suggests that these compositions, perceived as a prelude to life's denouement or embodying tranquil inner peace, continue to captivate scholars. These individuals, influenced by their temporal context and personal disposition, frequently fail to discern the subtlest nuances within the music.
Indeed, "masterpiece" is an overused term yet aptly describes the three works herein, with their enduring malleability that, almost two centuries on, still convey varied, and occasionally novel, messages that even their creators might not have anticipated. However, interpretative boundaries are inherently fluid, a notion exemplified by Schubert, Schumann, and Brahms. The three composers featured, though not virtuosos in the Lisztian sense, have each contributed emblematic pieces to the musical canon and have explored distinct spiritual dimensions through their artistry.
Commencing with Schubert, arguably the most emblematic of the trio, we consider his Sonata in C Minor, D. 958, one of the final three penned during the twilight of his life. Its dramatic intensity, structural anomalies, and the period of its inception closely align it with subsequent works and others like the "Winterreise" song cycle. In recent years, D. 958 in C Minor has become a favored piece among pianists striving to unravel its elusive essence, guiding listeners on a journey through a dreamscape of shadows and reverie, hinting at a solution to a conundrum that even the author might not have comprehended.
The enigma of Schumann's Op. 133, written shortly before his tragic descent into mental illness, presents a more complex case. Where Schubert's world remains accessible to all intrepid wanderers, Schumann's music encases the listener in a finite realm from which no journey can truly depart. It is challenging to reconcile this work as both a new expressive foray and a reflection of the composer's deep-seated turmoil. Described by his wife Clara during those fraught months as "very original as ever, but difficult to understand," Schumann's piece conveys a desire to transcend the ineffable, its profound harmonies cloaking an undercurrent of profound frustration.
Completing the record is Brahms' Op. 118, a stark contrast to the explorative wanderings of Schubert and the enigmatic finality of Schumann. Brahms appears more concerned with forging a distinct path, one less tethered to bygone virtuosity and more attuned to the introspective and the listener's experience within a tangible reality. Particularly in the sixth intermezzo, which concludes the collection, the sublimation of melody may resonate with intense poignancy.
Throughout these works, one perceives a consistent, grounded reality, echoing the Dantean aspiration to "see the stars again" and the culmination of a personal odyssey that engages with each individual's spiritual quest. In contemporary times, as ever, the search continues for that which remains undefined and may forever elude discovery. Yet, these composers suggest that it is not the attainment but the pursuit itself that encapsulates life's true beauty and grandeur.
Recording credits
Paolo Vergari, piano. Recorded at Paolo Vergari Studio, Albano Lake, Rome, in 2016. Piano: Yamaha CFX. Sound engineer: Massimo Marchese. Music advisor: Pasquale Punzo. Cover artwork: Utagawa Hiroshige, Full Moon at Takanawa (Takanawa no Meigetsu), c. 1831. ℗ & © Da Vinci Classics. DDD. Manufactured in Japan.