Deconstructing
The concept of musical form can be unhelpfully general: it tells us only that, in a work of art, material must be shaped and mediated rather than simply presented. In electronic music, form cannot be reduced to mathematical relationships. Such relationships certainly influence the compositional process, both as explicit principles and as latent, sometimes almost mystical structures; nevertheless, they are vehicles of form rather than form itself. The shaping of materials may appear chaotic and without inherent qualities to a subject who, for the first time, is left free and seemingly abandoned. The composer turns to mathematics because it can connect subjective reasoning with an appearance of objectivity: what confronts the artist as form may, paradoxically, reveal its opposite.
The characteristics for which radical art has been ostracised arise from its refusal to accommodate its content to an accepted harmony. It has challenged Romantic expressiveness through an uncompromising, almost documentary character and through its conflict with form. It refuses to soften the alienation of the image, absorbing that alienation only by recognising it as such. The rejection of meaning becomes a force through which the radical work can achieve synthesis: burdened with reflection, it denies its own significance in order to re-emerge as a formal principle.
A work of art is not fixed but in motion. Yet the accusation of chaos—often arising from an inability to follow a work’s own objective logic—is repeatedly directed against the most radical music. Under the constant threat of regression, the total rejection of style may itself become a style. A work shaped throughout by rational principles can overcome its separation from empirical existence precisely through its absolute autonomy.
Introductory text by Gabriele Zanetti, Peschiera del Garda, April 2018. Original English translation by Marianna Zanni.
John Dowland (1563–1626) — Can she excuse my wrongs?
Much about John Dowland’s early life remains uncertain, including his birthplace, which has been associated with both England and Ireland. The writer Thomas Fuller connected him with Westminster and the Dowlands recorded in the parish of St Martin-in-the-Fields. His career took him through the courts of Kassel and Brunswick and into Italy before his return to England in the winter of 1596. In London he published his first collection, The First Booke of Songes or Ayres of Foure Partes with Tableture for the Lute (1597). It was an extraordinary success and was reprinted at least four times. Its combination of vocal parts with lute tablature opened the repertoire to a wide range of performers. Whereas vocal music was commonly issued in separate partbooks, Dowland brought the parts together in a single large volume. The songs could be performed by a solo voice, by four voices without accompaniment, or with additional instruments.
Can she excuse my wrongs? takes the form of a galliard and can also be performed instrumentally, either by an ensemble or as a solo lute piece. Its accompaniment draws on the familiar Elizabethan tune Shall I go walk the woods so wild? Dowland’s persistent melancholy is evident from the beginning of his career. Sleep and death promise an early release from earthly concerns: although such ideas were characteristic of his age, his response is intensely personal. Death can also acquire an erotic significance, and even when this is absent or concealed, his treatment of the idea often retains an erotic intensity.
In Come heavy sleep, the listener is exposed to a passionate appeal that seems to break through the restraints of counterpoint. Benjamin Britten used this song as the basis of Nocturnal after John Dowland for guitar, Op. 70 (1963). Within the interpretative perspective of this programme, the deconstruction and transformation of musical material also provide a connection with Stockhausen’s Spiral, heard as track four.
Natasha Barrett (born 1972) — Deconstructing Dowland
Natasha Barrett is a British composer specialising in electroacoustic music. Her aesthetic is rooted in acousmatic listening: hearing a sound without seeing or identifying its original source. The term derives from the Greek akousmatikoi and its association with Pythagoras. It was revived by the French writer and poet Jérôme Peignot and developed theoretically by Pierre Schaeffer. Schaeffer used the concept to examine sound independently of the semantic and linguistic associations attached to its source, treating it as an object in its own right—the musical object. Recording and reproduction make this separation between sound and its cause possible.
Deconstructing Dowland (2003) takes Can she excuse my wrongs? as its starting material. Through the guitar’s intimate, introspective sound, it connects early music with acousmatic and surrealist aesthetics. The work is a duet between a guitarist, whose instrument is prepared by placing objects between the strings, and a computer. MaxMSP software mediates their interaction, responding to the guitarist’s performance within a precisely defined framework.
Sound itself takes precedence over conventional formal ideas: tones and timbres displace the familiar structural framework. The apparent freedom of the guitar suggests a more pervasive, almost obsessive order beneath the surface, developing as naturally and mysteriously as a luxuriant plant.
Luciano Berio (1925–2003) — Sequenza VIIb
Light and shadow, sound and silence are the first opposing pairs suggested by Sequenza VII. Dedicated to the Swiss oboist and conductor Heinz Holliger, the original work explores the most extreme possibilities of instrumental technique and timbre. An imagined polyphony unfolds with acrobatic agility against a continuously sustained reference pitch. Claude Delangle, a leading interpreter of contemporary saxophone music, prepared the adaptation for soprano saxophone, Sequenza VIIb.
Small, sometimes almost imperceptible changes of timbre produce vocal-like nuances. Sound and silence interact along a path through a dense, constantly changing and elusive acoustic environment. The process begins with a single fundamental note, sustained by an oscillator throughout the piece. At times it is clearly defined; at others its presence becomes more ambiguous, transformed through different colours of sound. The result evokes an imaginary bodily dimension, with continually changing expression and mood. Sound quality is therefore central to Berio’s language: the Sequenza becomes an exploration of a sound source moving through non-tonal spaces of enquiry.
Karlheinz Stockhausen (1928–2007) — Spiral
Stockhausen was one of the most significant composers of the twentieth century, exceptionally persistent in pursuing new ideas and precise in formulating an avant-garde mission. Spiral belongs to a group of works from the 1960s that he described as process compositions. These separate form from content by giving the performers transformation signs to apply to material that can differ substantially from one performance to another. In Spiral and the related works Kurzwellen for six performers, Pole for two and Expo for three, this material is drawn spontaneously from radio broadcasts during the performance.
The processes, represented principally by plus, minus and equals signs, constitute the composition. Although the material is unpredictable, the processes provide a framework that remains recognisable from one performance to another. Spiral was composed in Madison, Connecticut, in September 1968 and first performed at the Zagreb Music Biennale on 15 May 1969, with Heinz Holliger as soloist. It comprises 206 events grouped into ten sections, separated by wavy lines. Each plus, minus or equals sign instructs the performer, when repeating an event, to increase, decrease or maintain one of four dimensions: the event’s overall duration, its number of internal subdivisions, its dynamic level or its register and pitch range. The performer chooses which dimension to affect; vertically stacked signs must apply to different parameters.
Sound and its environment thus become conditions for a form of hysteresis. In this phenomenon, the value of a quantity depends not only on the present values of the variables affecting it, but also on their previous states. A system’s response to a stimulus therefore retains a memory of what came before. Here hysteresis becomes the rhythm of the eye: an eye that becomes an ear.
The booklet’s image of schizophrenia is philosophical rather than a literal description of dissociation. Music, imagined as disembodying bodies, follows lines of flight that pass through them but find their consistency elsewhere. This emerges both in the introduction of timbre—that longstanding preoccupation of instrumental improvisers—and in the use of pure patterns of sound. At the boundaries between the infinitely large and the infinitely small, abstraction and figuration, the blackness of night and the whiteness of the stars, like an inverted, infinite keyboard, Stockhausen’s music vibrates within the silence of the universe, interpreting the limitless possibilities of space and time.
It suggests the boundless space of a universe we do not know, and the immeasurable time of a world we do not understand. Sounds become universal messages, capable of crossing time without being diminished by it, because they challenge nothingness itself.
JacobTV (born 1951) — The Garden of Love
The Dutch composer JacobTV, Jacob ter Veldhuis, describes his music as avant-pop. His instrumental works often combine live performance with an emotionally powerful recorded soundtrack, playable through a boombox. They draw inspiration from the rhythms and sounds of everyday conversation, contemporary subjects and events around the world. The Garden of Love takes its inspiration from William Blake’s poem. The soundtrack accompanying the soprano saxophone contains the words of the poem alongside sampled oboe and harpsichord sounds, birds, electronic string sounds and percussion.
Ulrich Krieger (born 1962) — PYII
Imagination, inspiration and creativity characterise the work of Ulrich Krieger, a composer and performer born in Freiburg, Germany, in 1962. PYII evokes the experimental atmosphere of progressive rock and embraces an element of chance. Within a few minutes, it brings together compositional approaches developed from the late twentieth century onwards. Measured passages alternate with guided improvisation. Structures specified in meticulous detail coexist with sections in which the performers—soprano saxophone, electric guitar, electric bass and drums—can combine the basic ingredients according to their own judgement.
Particularly striking is the use of multiphonics on the soprano saxophone: blocks of sound blossom from a single note and enter into dialogue with the complex harmonic texture. These overlapping pitches are produced through combinations of fingerings and changes in the airflow and articulation, bringing selected notes within the implied harmony or disharmony into focus. Meditative passages on the electric guitar form boundaries between the work’s different structures.
Morton Feldman (1926–1987) — The Possibility of a New Work
Morton Feldman’s distinctive approach helped transform the landscape of American music. His search for a music of pure essence produced writing apparently freed from ordinary acoustic associations: pristine sound that addresses the listener softly, sometimes angular, sometimes slow and distant. This uncompromising aesthetic develops beyond the example of John Cage, an important friend, influence and source of artistic inspiration.
The work’s realisation also owes something to practical experimentation during its preparation, in collaboration with Christian Wolff, its first performer. The original manuscript subsequently disappeared from Wolff’s possession.
Barry Cockcroft — Rock Me!
Rock Me! combines irrepressible energy with the groove and rhythm of rock music. A firmly articulated pulse leaves room for gradual dynamic changes and the exploration of contrasting tone colours. The music conveys exuberant joy and vitality, and the saxophone imitates other instruments associated with the genre: the attack and distortion of a guitar, the snare drum, bass drum and hi-hat.
Rapid blues figures, unexpected changes of feel and sudden dynamic contrasts are only some of the work’s features. Contemporary saxophone techniques are placed entirely at the service of the music, rather than displayed as technical exercises. Harmonics with and without an audible fundamental, two- and three-note multiphonics, wailing effects, closed and open slap tonguing, unpitched slaps, crossfades and growls become expressive elements in this excursion into the language of popular music.
Patrick Roux (born 1962) — Soledad
Alongside his active career as a performer and composer, Patrick Roux has taught at the Conservatoire de musique du Québec in Gatineau since 1985, at the University of Ottawa since 1993 and on the summer courses of the Domaine Forget International Music and Dance Academy.
Soledad begins with a brief introduction for solo guitar, opening into a melancholy dialogue. More forceful harmonies and rhythms colour the central section. A guitar cadenza and a return of earlier material lead towards a coda that leaves many questions unresolved. The mood is sorrowful without being theatrical: it offers a clear-eyed, at times resigned view of solitude. Although solitude may seem a source of distress, it can also be a condition in which happiness—and perhaps true freedom—becomes possible.
Programme notes by Lorenzo Ricchelli and Gabriele Zanetti. Original English translation by Camilla Ravagnani. Text adapted to the current nine-track digital programme, with language and factual corrections.