Written for string quartet in 1890, Crisantemi opens a path into Puccini’s theatre through music that first existed without a stage or a singer.

An operatic melody can seem inseparable from the character who sings it. Its shape appears to belong to a particular predicament, as though the words and dramatic situation had called it into existence. Puccini’s Crisantemi asks us to reconsider that impression. Material from this short instrumental elegy would later enter Manon Lescaut, acquiring another life inside the theatre.

Composed in 1890 for string quartet, Crisantemi was dedicated to the memory of Amedeo di Savoia, Duke of Aosta. Its setting is therefore commemorative, with four instrumental lines carrying an expression of mourning. There is no libretto to establish the identity of a speaker or explain the cause of each expressive turn. The musical relationships have to articulate their own continuity.

Puccini subsequently reused material from the work in Manon Lescaut. The connection is more revealing than the simple discovery of an earlier source. Once placed within an opera, a phrase meets voices, words, orchestral colours and dramatic circumstances. Its musical contour may be recognisable, yet its significance has changed. A gesture of lament becomes attached to people whose story gives it a different precision.

Hearing the quartet independently reverses that process. The phrase is released from the character we may have learned to associate with it. Attention can move towards the distribution of its lines: where the melody passes, what the accompanying parts sustain, how a harmonic change delays or permits a cadence. These are the resources through which a small instrumental work establishes the scale of its feeling.

This movement between media is especially instructive in Puccini because the voice is so central to our understanding of his achievement. Instrumental pieces allow us to examine aspects of the musical language before we supply the words of a familiar aria. The exercise does not require us to strip the music of expression. It asks how expression is made audible through intervals, harmonic direction, articulation and the timing of a phrase.

A further transcription introduces another set of decisions. In Pucciniana, Crisantemi is heard on two guitars. Bowed strings can renew a sustained note through a continuous gesture; a plucked string begins with an attack and then decays. Maintaining a line therefore becomes a question of spacing, voicing and resonance. The transcription gives the player a different means of shaping continuity, while leaving the listener able to follow the work’s melodic relationships.

The passage from quartet to opera and from quartet to guitar duo makes three distinct acts of listening possible. Each medium gives particular elements prominence. A familiar melody can be followed backwards towards its instrumental source, then heard again under changed acoustic conditions. Crisantemi is a compact reminder that a musical idea has a history before and beyond the dramatic identity through which we happen to know it.

DV © 2026