Bresciaoggi
“un contributo raffinato”
An appreciative response to Maurizio Paciariello and Susanna Pisana’s Luchesi sonatas on historical instruments. Published in the newspaper’s classical record column.
Da Vinci Classics
Maurizio Paciariello, Susanna Pisana
Physical and Digital Release: 19 January 2018
The complete collection of accompanied keyboard sonatas, published in Bonn in 1772, performed on a Haselmann fortepiano from around 1810 and a Bernardo Calcagni violin from around 1740.
Andrea Luchesi: Six Sonatas, Op. 1
Maurizio Paciariello , fortepiano · Susanna Pisana , violin
13.67€
Digital programme · 18 tracks
Track timings and movement titles refer to the digital edition.
Maurizio Paciariello studied with Giuseppe Scotese at the Santa Cecilia Conservatory in Rome, graduating with top marks and distinction. He subsequently undertook advanced studies with Aldo Ciccolini and studied chamber music with Paul Badura-Skoda at the Accademia Chigiana in Siena and Norbert Brainin at the Scuola di Musica di Fiesole. He received a prize at the 47th ARD International Music Competition in Munich in 1998 and made his Carnegie Hall debut in New York in 2003.
His repertoire encompasses solo and chamber music, with a particular interest in period instruments. The instruments he has used include a copy of a late eighteenth-century clavichord, an early nineteenth-century Viennese Haselmann fortepiano, a French Boisselot piano dating from around 1840 and an 1885 Bösendorfer. His exploration of historical performance practice has led to projects such as Beethoven’s complete violin sonatas on an 1804 Broadwood piano at the Museum of the American Piano in New York, as well as a performance at the Cappella Paolina in the Quirinale Palace, Rome.
His recording debut for Inedita featured the piano concertos of Friedrich Kuhlau and Franz Berwald with the Sassari Symphony Orchestra. For the same label, he recorded Beethoven’s youthful Concerto in E-flat major, WoO 4 (1784), which attracted favourable attention in Italy and abroad. Further research resulted in recordings of the Rondo in B-flat major and the Concerto in D major, Op. 61a, receiving an enthusiastic response from international musicologists and consideration for the Prix International du Disque in Cannes. The seventh volume of Beethoven Rarities (Inedita), featuring the 1808 manuscript version of the Fourth Concerto, Op. 58, and the Second Concerto, Op. 19, with the handwritten cadenza from the Kafka Sketchbook, received five stars in Musica.
His ASV recording of Christian Sinding’s music for violin and piano received praise from Fanfare, BBC News, The Guardian and The Daily Telegraph. With Luca Sanzò he recorded the viola sonatas of Lino Liviabella and Nino Rota, and with Marco Rogliano the complete works for violin and piano by Ottorino Respighi (Tactus). His recording of Paul Hindemith’s viola sonatas with Sanzò (Brilliant Classics) received favourable notices from Gramophone, Fanfare, MusicWeb International, Musica and Opusklassiek. Reviewing his recording of Hindemith’s three piano sonatas for Fanfare, James H. North described him as “a Gustav Leonhardt turned into a Van Cliburn”.
Susanna Pisana began studying the violin with her father and continued her training with Norbert Brainin, leader of the Amadeus Quartet, developing a particular interest in chamber music.
She has performed at venues in Rome including the Auditorium Parco della Musica, Teatro Argentina, Auditorium del Foro Italico, Teatro Olimpico, Globe Theatre and Teatro di Documenti, and in Milan at I Pomeriggi Musicali and Teatro dell’Arte. Her festival appearances include the early music festival in Urbino, the Cantiere Internazionale d’Arte in Montepulciano and the Società Aquilana dei Concerti “B. Barattelli” in L’Aquila.
She has explored historically informed Baroque performance on period instruments, playing a violin by Bernardo Calcagni dating from around 1740, and has performed with Rinaldo Alessandrini’s Concerto Italiano. Her interest in performance practice also extends to contemporary music, in which she has collaborated with the Freon Group and the “G. Petrassi” chamber ensemble.
In 2006 she performed in a live radio broadcast with the Michelangelo Quartet at the Cappella Paolina in the Quirinale Palace, in the presence of Giorgio Napolitano, President of the Italian Republic. From 1991 to 2007 she taught violin and served as concertmaster at the Scuola Popolare di Musica di Testaccio in Rome.
Andrea Luchesi (b Motta di Livenza, nr Treviso, 23 May 1741; d Bonn, 21 March 1801). Italian composer. By 1757 he was in Venice where, according to Neefe, he was trained ‘in the theatrical style’ by Gioacchino Cocchi, and ‘in the church style’ by Padre Giuseppe Paolucci and Giuseppe Saratelli, the maestro di cappella of S Marco. From 1765, with the support of his patron, the music theorist Count Giordano Riccati, Lucchesi made a name for himself in Venice as an opera composer and wrote sacred and secular occasional works on commission. He also travelled to neighbouring cities as a virtuoso performer on the harpsichord and particularly organ. In 1768, for instance, he played for the dedication of the organ in Padua Cathedral.
In 1771, like many of his colleagues, he went to Germany as the director of a travelling opera company. A decree of 26 May 1774 from the Elector Archbishop of Cologne appointed him court Kapellmeister in Bonn, succeeding Beethoven's grandfather. In 1775 he married into the distinguished d'Anthoin family. As the opera company had dispersed and the court theatre had been closed, Lucchesi was now principally active as a composer of church music. Nonetheless, he still wrote a few small-scale stage works, and in 1785 composed a serenata for the elector on the occasion of his consecration as bishop. However, the musical direction of the Nationaltheater in Bonn, built in 1778, was in the hands of the court organist C.G. Neefe, while instrumental music at the court was the responsibility first of the violinist Gaetano Mattioli and later Josef Reicha.
Apart from a visit in 1783–4 to Venice, where Lucchesi produced his opera seria Ademira, and where he probably received the title of director of the Accademia Musical de' Tedeschi, Lucchesi remained in Bonn until the court was dissolved after the French occupation of the Rhineland in 1794. In 1787 he was appointed Titularrat. From 1782 to 1792 the young Beethoven was a member of the court Kapelle, first as assistant organist, then as harpsichordist and viola player. In addition to Neefe's teaching and his experience in Reicha's orchestra, Beethoven's musical development must have been considerably influenced by Lucchesi, who, as Kapellmeister, determined the repertory of sacred music performed at the court. After the elector's flight in 1794 and in the event of the court returning, plans for church music on a smaller scale were entrusted to Lucchesi. However, they came to nothing, and his final years were spent in poverty and obscurity.
In line with his career, Lucchesi's works can be divided into the operas and instrumental works of his time in Venice and early years in Bonn, and his sacred music for the electoral Kapelle. His secular works were performed in many different European cities, ranging from Lisbon, where one of his operas was performed, to Stockholm and Prague, where several of his symphonies found their way into the archives. While he had been most famous for his organ works in Italy, according to La Borde his symphonies were held in particularly high esteem in Germany, a notable achievement for an Italian at this time. Leopold Mozart, writing in his 1771 diary of his Venetian travels, described Lucchesi as a maestro di cemballo and liked to use one of his harpsichord concertos when teaching. Although only a few of Lucchesi's works appeared in print, his Sei sonate op.1 for harpsichord and violin (1772), was the first music to be printed in Bonn. Lucchesi's sacred music, apart from the early works (mostly lost), is now at the Biblioteca Estense in Modena, together with a large part of the manuscript and printed music from the elector's collection. Apart from many compositions for liturgical use, his sacred works include a Passion to a Metastasio libretto for concertante performance during Holy Week.
Various contemporary assessments of Lucchesi's style have come down to us. Burney called him ‘a very pleasing composer’, while La Borde speaks of ‘a particularly graceful style, concise and energetic arrangement of the parts, and new ideas’. Neefe described him as ‘a light, agreeable and lively composer, whose counterpoint is cleaner than that of many of his countrymen’, adding, however, that in his sacred works he ‘does not always confine himself to the strict style’. Lucchesi's approach to sacred music reconciled the stile antico and the stile moderno, combining an early form of the imitation of Palestrina with the secularized, fashionable operatic style of the 18th century. It was entirely in the spirit of the contemporary theory of church music that he had learnt from his teacher Paolucci (a pupil of Padre Martini) and from Vallotti in Padua.
Album notes By Edmondo Filippini. English revised from the original booklet. Andrea Luchesi attracted the admiration of several distinguished contemporaries. Charles Burney called him “a very pleasing composer”, while Jean-Benjamin de La Borde praised “a particularly graceful style, concise and energetic arrangement of the parts, and new ideas”. Christian Gottlob Neefe described him as “a light, agreeable and lively composer, whose counterpoint is cleaner than that of many of his countrymen”. Leopold Mozart, meanwhile, liked to use one of his harpsichord concertos in his teaching. Such testimony suggests a composer…
By Edmondo Filippini. English revised from the original booklet.
Andrea Luchesi attracted the admiration of several distinguished contemporaries. Charles Burney called him “a very pleasing composer”, while Jean-Benjamin de La Borde praised “a particularly graceful style, concise and energetic arrangement of the parts, and new ideas”. Christian Gottlob Neefe described him as “a light, agreeable and lively composer, whose counterpoint is cleaner than that of many of his countrymen”. Leopold Mozart, meanwhile, liked to use one of his harpsichord concertos in his teaching. Such testimony suggests a composer who was respected during his lifetime, even though his name subsequently faded from musical history. Contemporary praise alone, however, cannot explain a composer’s achievement: fortunately, enough of Luchesi’s music survives to give us a clear impression of his style and the qualities that his contemporaries admired.
Relatively little is known about his early life. Like many eighteenth-century Kapellmeisters and music masters, he enjoyed the security of a court appointment but was largely forgotten after his death. Born in Motta di Livenza, near Treviso, on 23 May 1741, Luchesi was in Venice by 1757, according to Neefe. There he studied with Gioacchino Cocchi, Padre Giuseppe Paolucci and Giuseppe Saratelli, maestro di cappella at San Marco. Beyond these accounts, firm information about his earliest training remains limited.
From 1765 Luchesi established himself in Venice as an opera composer and wrote sacred and secular occasional works, supported by his patron, the music theorist Count Giordano Riccati. In 1771 he travelled to Germany with an opera company and settled in Bonn. He was appointed court Kapellmeister by the Elector-Archbishop of Cologne in May 1774 and married into the distinguished d’Anthoin family in 1775. His position offered professional and personal stability, while he continued to achieve success in opera: Ademira, for example, was staged in Venice in 1784.
Musical responsibilities at the Bonn court were divided among several musicians. Christian Gottlob Neefe, the court organist and Beethoven’s teacher, directed music at the Nationaltheater; instrumental music was entrusted first to the violinist Gaetano Mattioli and later to Josef Reicha. Luchesi was principally responsible for church music, with the considerable work of selecting repertoire, coordinating musicians and organising performances. The young Beethoven served in the court Kapelle, and Luchesi’s programming formed part of the musical environment in which he developed.
Luchesi’s surviving output reflects these stages of his career. His operas and instrumental works from Venice and his early years in Bonn show the influence of contemporary musical styles. His later sacred music sought to reconcile Italian and German traditions, bringing together stile antico and stile moderno. After the court was dissolved following the French occupation in 1794, Luchesi remained in Bonn, where he died on 21 March 1801.
The six sonatas recorded here, Sei sonate per il clavicembalo con l’accompagnamento di un violino, Op. 1, belong to the beginning of his Bonn period. Published there in 1772, they were among the few works that appeared in print during his lifetime. Their title makes the relationship between the instruments explicit: the keyboard takes the leading role, while the violin provides an accompaniment. Often it reinforces the harmony, entering into a more independent dialogue with the keyboard only occasionally.
This balance is especially apparent in the Allegro and Presto movements, where the keyboard remains the principal protagonist. The slower movements allow the violin a little more room, although its full expressive potential is seldom explored. Grace and lightness are central to these sonatas, as they are to much occasional music of the period; the writing favours elegance and clarity over sustained instrumental dialogue or emotional depth. Luchesi has a plentiful supply of ideas and a clear concern for disciplined construction, but these pieces show little desire to challenge the conventions of their genre.
The Sixth Sonata in D major offers a telling example. Its brilliant opening Allegro molto presents quick-moving melodic ideas in the keyboard. A melancholy Andante follows, introduced by the keyboard, and for a moment the violin seems ready to assume a more prominent expressive role. The music soon returns, however, to its established balance and familiar conventions. These sonatas do not seek to redefine the genre, and it would be misleading to judge them solely by that expectation. They offer instead an attractive and revealing glimpse of musical taste in Germany in the 1770s. Listening to them helps us understand the qualities praised by Burney and La Borde: a gracious, lucid and light-footed musical language characteristic of its time.
Maurizio Paciariello — fortepiano by Haselmann, circa 1810.
Susanna Pisana — violin by Bernardo Calcagni, circa 1740.
Recorded at the Palazzo dei Priori, Tarquinia, Italy, on 12–13 January 2015.
Sound engineer: Davide Farace.
Artistic director: Luca Sanzò.
Editing and mixing: Maurizio Paciariello.
Cover photograph: Schlosskirche of the Rheinische Friedrich-Wilhelms-Universität, Bonn.
Production, design and art direction: OMK-Da Vinci.
Printed with the support of S.P.L.M.
Selected awards, reviews and interviews. Radio broadcasts and podcasts are listed separately below.
Bresciaoggi
Review · Luigi Fertonani · 26 June 2018
“un contributo raffinato”
An appreciative response to Maurizio Paciariello and Susanna Pisana’s Luchesi sonatas on historical instruments. Published in the newspaper’s classical record column.
Broadcasts, conversations and listening features dedicated to this recording.
RTP Antena 2 · Notas Finais
Radio · António Pires Veloso · 22 August 2022
The official programme for 22 August 2022 lists Luchesi’s Sonata No. 3 in A major, Op. 1, performed by Maurizio Paciariello and Susanna Pisana, in Notas Finais at 06:00. The link opens the contemporary programme bulletin; an audio replay has not been verified.
Explore the broadcast ↗ - RTP Antena 2 · Notas Finais